For over three decades after it attained independence
in 1960, Côte d'Ivoire enjoyed political stability and relative
socio-economic prosperity under its founding leader, President Félix
Houphouët-Boigny. As a result, the country attracted large numbers
of foreign workers, mostly from neighbouring countries, as well
as investors. Following the death of President Houphouët-Boigny
on 7 December 1993, Côte d'Ivoire was plunged into a protracted
power struggle, which generated intense political instability and
culminated in December 1999 in a coup d'état, led by General Robert
Gueï, who overthrew President Henri Konan Bédié.
The post-Houphouët-Boigny power struggle was exacerbated
by the controversies over nationality laws and eligibility conditions
for national elections, particularly the presidential elections,
which resulted in the disqualification of some prominent political
leaders, including Alassane Ouattara of the Rally of the Republicans
(RDR). These issues came to a head during the presidential elections
of October 2000.
The heated dispute over the results of those presidential
elections resulted in violent clashes between the partisans of the
two main contenders - General Gueï and Laurent Gbagbo. Subsequently,
the Supreme Court declared Mr. Gbagbo the winner of those elections.
Those clashes claimed the lives of over 50 people, however, and
a mass grave was subsequently discovered near the northern Abidjan
suburb of Yopougon.
Despite an alleged coup attempt in January 2001,
which was blamed on foreigners and resulted in large numbers of
immigrant workers from Burkina Faso leaving Côte d'Ivoire, scheduled
municipal elections were held in March 2001. The municipal elections
marked an important turning point for Côte d'Ivoire, as all political
parties were allowed to field candidates for the elections. Mr.
Ouattara's RDR party won in the largest number of communes. Following
those elections, President Gbagbo pursued a policy of national reconciliation
and sought to decentralize State authority by organizing provincial
elections.
In October 2001, the President organized a forum
for national reconciliation to address the issues that had polarized
the Ivorian people, including the questions of nationality, land
ownership, the disputed legitimacy of his government and the conditions
of service of the security forces. The forum culminated in a summit
meeting attended by President Gbagbo, Mr. Bédié, General Gueï and
Mr. Ouattara on 22 and 23 January 2002 to settle their differences
and consider the recommendations of the forum. The four leaders
subsequently issued a final communiqué in which, among other things,
they agreed to oppose undemocratic avenues to power, and to professionalize
the security forces and improve their conditions of service. They
further agreed to create a broad-based national electoral commission
and a national body to address the question of land ownership.
The leaders also addressed the issue of the legitimacy
of the current government and agreed to form a new government of
national unity. In July 2002, President Gbagbo held a further meeting
with Mr. Ouattara and Mr. Bédié in Yamoussoukro, which led to the
formation of a broad-based government on 5 August 2002. All of Côte
d'Ivoire's main opposition political parties were included in the
new cabinet, 20 portfolios being allocated to the ruling Ivorian
Popular Front (FPI) and 4 to Mr. Ouattara's RDR, while 7 went to
Mr. Bédié's former ruling Democratic Party of Côte d'Ivoire (PDCI),
2 to the Ivorian Workers Party (PIT) of Francis Wodié and 1 to General
Gueï's Union for Democracy and Peace in Côte d'Ivoire (UDPCI). The
long-standing controversy over Mr. Ouattara's nationality, which
had become a major source of political tension and instability,
was also finally resolved when a court delivered a nationality certificate
to him on 26 July 2002. Unfortunately, not all of the recommendations
of the forum for national reconciliation were implemented.
Current crisis
Regrettably, these encouraging steps towards national
reconciliation and reducing tensions in Côte d'Ivoire were disrupted
by the current crisis, which erupted on 19 September 2002. The crisis
started with simultaneous attacks on military installations in the
capital, Abidjan, and the second largest city, Bouaké, and in the
northern town of Korhogo by some 800 soldiers, ostensibly to protest
against their planned demobilization early in 2003. Most of those
soldiers had been recruited during the military regime of General
Gueï.
While loyalist security forces quickly regained
control of the situation in Abidjan, the rebels retained control
of Bouaké and Korhogo and subsequently seized other towns in the
northern and western regions of the country, as other disgruntled
soldiers and civilians swelled their ranks. General Gueï, together
with several members of his family, as well as the Minister of the
Interior, Emile Boga Doudou, were among the people killed during
the incidents in Abidjan. Although the initial attacks were widely
believed to be a mutiny, there were also allegations that the rebellion
was an attempted coup d'état supported by foreign elements, which
prompted widespread harassment of foreigners, including migrant
workers from neighbouring countries, as well as refugees from Liberia
and Sierra Leone, whose dwellings in shanty towns in Abidjan and
San-Pédro were burned down by the security forces. In Abidjan, the
destruction of squatter settlements displaced some 20,000 people.
Loyalist security forces launched several military
operations to dislodge the rebel soldiers from the seized towns,
without success. By the end of September, the rebel forces had consolidated
their hold on the northern half of the country and were operating
under the umbrella of a political movement calling itself the Patriotic
Movement of Côte d'Ivoire (MPCI). Through its spokesman, Guillaume
Soro, a former student leader, the movement identified its key demands
as the resignation of President Gbagbo, the holding of inclusive
national elections, a review of the Constitution and an end to the
domination of southerners in the affairs of the country. The conflict
was further compounded by the emergence of two new armed groups,
the Ivorian Popular Movement of the Great West (MPIGO) and the Movement
for Justice and Peace (MJP), who seized the towns of Danané and
Man in November 2002. Both groups declared that their main objective
was to avenge the death of General Gueï and they also demanded the
resignation of President Gbagbo.
The Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS)
took swift steps to search for a solution to the crisis. On 29 September
the subregional organization convened an emergency summit meeting
in Accra, which set up a contact group comprising Ghana, Guinea-Bissau,
Mali, the Niger, Nigeria and Togo, together with the African Union,
to promote dialogue between the rebels and the Government of Côte
d'Ivoire, and to discuss a general framework to resolve the crisis.
The summit was followed by a meeting of the ECOWAS Defence and Security
Commission, which recommended that immediate arrangements be put
in place to deploy ECOWAS troops to Côte d'Ivoire. The approved
mandate of the ECOWAS force included monitoring a proposed ceasefire,
ensuring the disengagement of the insurgents from the areas that
had fallen under their control, and disarming the rebel groups.
The ECOWAS Contact Group on Côte d'Ivoire began
its mediation efforts on 30 September 2002 with a meeting with President
Gbagbo in Abidjan. On 3 October, members of the Group, accompanied
by the Executive Secretary of ECOWAS, Mohamed Ibn Chambas, and the
Interim Chairman of the Commission of the African Union, Amara Essy,
met with the leaders of MPCI in Bouaké. The mediation efforts continued
until 6 October when the Contact Group left the country after the
Government thrice postponed signing a ceasefire agreement, on the
grounds that the agreement would result in legitimizing the rebel
movement and partitioning the country. On 11 October, Cheikh Tidiane
Gadio, the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Senegal, which was then
holding the chairmanship of ECOWAS, renewed the efforts to broker
a ceasefire. The Executive Secretary of ECOWAS, together with my
Special Representative for West Africa, Ahmedou Ould-Abdallah, participated
in Foreign Minister Gadio's talks with President Gbagbo in Abidjan
and with MPCI in Bouaké. These efforts culminated in the signing
by MPCI on 17 October 2002 of a ceasefire agreement, which was subsequently
accepted by President Gbagbo in an address to the nation on the
same day.
In accepting the cessation of hostilities, President
Gbagbo announced that he had requested France to assign forces to
monitor the ceasefire, pending the deployment of ECOWAS troops.
As indicated in the letter dated 21 February 2003 from the Permanent
Representative of France to the President of the Security Council,
the forces of Operation Licorne were already based in Côte d'Ivoire
under long-standing bilateral defence arrangements.
The Lomé talks
The ceasefire agreement of 17 October paved the
way for negotiations on a political agreement between the Government
and MPCI. The peace talks between the two sides began in Lomé on
24 October 2002 under the auspices of the President of Togo, Gnassingbé
Eyadéma, who had been designated by the ECOWAS Contact Group to
lead the negotiations. On 31 October, the Lomé talks yielded the
first agreement, under which the two parties reaffirmed their commitment
to the ceasefire agreement, pledged to refrain from human rights
abuses, and acknowledged the need to preserve the territorial integrity
of Côte d'Ivoire and to respect the country's institutions. A further
agreement was signed on 1 November, under which the Government,
among other things, agreed to submit to the National Assembly a
draft amnesty law, which would include freeing jailed members of
the military and permitting the return of exiled soldiers, who would
be reintegrated into the army. The Lomé talks subsequently stalled,
however, as MPCI insisted on the resignation of President Gbagbo,
a review of the Constitution and the holding of fresh elections,
while the Government demanded that the rebels disarm and honour
their commitment to preserve the territorial integrity of the country.
Despite intensive efforts by the ECOWAS leaders
to break the stalemate, including the submission of a compromise
draft peace plan by President Eyadéma on 21 November 2002, and a
series of meetings among the ECOWAS leaders in Kara, Togo, as well
as in Abidjan and Dakar on 16 and 18 December 2002, the two sides
would not return to the Lomé talks. At their meeting in Dakar on
18 December, the ECOWAS leaders decided that the ECOWAS Peace Force
for Côte d'Ivoire (ECOFORCE) would be deployed by 31 December 2002.
They also appointed General Papa Khalil Fall (Senegal) as the Force
Commander of ECOFORCE and Raph Uwechue (Nigeria), as the Special
Representative of the Executive Secretary of ECOWAS for Côte d'Ivoire.
The leaders appealed to the African Union and the United Nations
to step up their involvement in assisting ECOWAS to resolve the
Ivorian crisis. They also requested the Chairman of ECOWAS, as well
as France and the African members of the Security Council, to bring
the issue of Côte d'Ivoire before the Council.
In a fresh initiative, the Minister for Foreign
Affairs of France, Dominique de Villepin, visited Côte d'Ivoire
on 3 and 4 January 2003 for consultations with the Government, political
parties and the rebel movements, during which he secured the agreement
of all Ivorian political groups to attend a round-table meeting
in France. At the same time, the ECOWAS peace efforts yielded complementary
progress when President Eyadéma brokered an agreement on cessation
of hostilities between the Government and the two western-based
rebel movements, MPIGO and MJP, who had not been part of the ceasefire
agreement of 17 October 2002.
The Linas-Marcoussis Agreement
As indicated during my briefing to the Security
Council on 28 January 2003, the round-table meeting of the Ivorian
political groups was held at Linas-Marcoussis, France, from 15 to
23 January 2003 with the participation of the Ivorian Popular Front,
the Movement of Future Forces (MFA), the Movement for Justice and
Peace, the Patriotic Movement of Côte d'Ivoire, the Ivorian Popular
Movement of the Great West, the Democratic Party of Côte d'Ivoire-African
Democratic Party (PDCI-RDA), the Ivorian Workers Party, the Rally
of the Republicans, the Democratic Union of Côte d'Ivoire (UDCI)
and the Union for Democracy and Peace in Côte d'Ivoire. The round
table was chaired by the Chairman of the French Constitutional Commission,
Pierre Mazeaud, assisted by Judge Keba Mbaye (Senegal) and the former
Prime Minister of Côte d'Ivoire, Seydou Diarra, as well as representatives
from the African Union and ECOWAS and my Special Representative
for West Africa as facilitators.
The round table resulted in the signing of the
Linas-Marcoussis Agreement (S/2003/99, annex I) on 23 January 2003
by all Ivorian political forces. It may be recalled that the principal
provisions of the Agreement include the creation of a government
of national reconciliation, to be headed by a Prime Minister appointed
by the President in consultation with other political parties. The
President would delegate substantial powers to the Prime Minister,
whose mandate would last until the next national elections, which
are scheduled for 2005. The Prime Minister would not be eligible
to stand as a candidate in those elections.
The Linas-Marcoussis Agreement also defined the
main tasks of the new government of national reconciliation, which
include preparing a timetable for credible and transparent national
elections, restructuring the defence and security forces, and organizing
the regrouping and disarmament of all armed groups. An annex to
the Agreement also set out a programme for resolving issues that
constituted the root causes of instability in Côte d'Ivoire, such
as the question of citizenship, the status of foreign nationals,
eligibility to run for the presidency of the country, incitement
to hatred and xenophobia by certain media, the creation of a human
rights commission consisting of representatives from all parties,
the drawing up of a voters roll, the independence of the justice
system with respect to electoral disputes, and the implementation
of a land tenure regime.
The peace Agreement provided for the establishment
of a committee to follow up on the implementation of the Agreement
(the Follow-Up Committee). The Committee will be based in Abidjan.
It is composed of representatives of the United Nations, the African
Union, ECOWAS, the European Commission, the International Organization
of la Francophonie, the Bretton Woods institutions, the Group of
Eight countries, the European Union, a military representative of
the troop-contributing countries and France. A meeting of the heads
of State of concerned African countries and France, which was held
in Paris on 25 and 26 January 2003, endorsed the Linas-Marcoussis
Agreement. During that meeting, President Gbagbo, in consultation
with other Ivorian parties, appointed the former Prime Minister,
Seydou Diarra, to head the new government of national reconciliation.
In addition, during consultations conducted on the sidelines of
the meeting, an understanding was reached on an arrangement for
the distribution of cabinet posts among the Ivorian parties, under
which the key portfolios of defence and the interior were allocated
to the rebel movements.
Both the Linas-Marcoussis Agreement and the conclusions
adopted by the heads of State in Paris on 26 January 2003 (S/2003/99,
annex II) envisaged a United Nations role in the implementation
of the Agreement, including participating in and chairing the Follow-Up
Committee. The Agreement stipulated that the new Ivorian government
of national reconciliation would seek assistance from ECOWAS, France
and the United Nations in guaranteeing the reform and restructuring
of the defence and security forces; international development partners
are requested to cooperate with the new government in putting in
place a programme for the reintegration of all armed elements. In
their communiqué, the heads of State proposed the strengthening
of the presence of the United Nations system in Côte d'Ivoire, in
particular in the areas of security, humanitarian assistance and
human rights, as well as the deployment of civilian and military
observers, who would help to supervise the implementation of the
Linas-Marcoussis Agreement. They also expressed the wish that the
Security Council would endorse the peacekeeping operation launched
by ECOWAS and France, and authorize that operation to take the necessary
measures to ensure the freedom of movement and security of its personnel,
and to guarantee the protection of civilians facing the imminent
threat of violence.
Developments since the Linas-Marcoussis Agreement
The implementation of the Linas-Marcoussis Agreement
encountered serious obstacles soon after the conclusion of the Paris
summit. The newly appointed Prime Minister of the envisaged government
of national reconciliation, Seydou Diarra, was unable to travel
immediately to Côte d'Ivoire to take up his post as head of the
new government, because of a series of massive and often violent
demonstrations that erupted in Abidjan and other towns to protest
against the allocation of the Ministries of Defence and the Interior
to the rebel movements. During those demonstrations, French interests
and installations in Abidjan were targeted and deliberately attacked.
In addition to the demonstrations, the leaders
of Côte d'Ivoire's defence forces wrote to President Gbagbo expressing
their opposition to the participation of the rebel movements in
the new government. The leaders of major political parties who signed
the Linas-Marcoussis Agreement also rejected the allocation of the
defence and interior portfolios to the rebel movements, while the
incumbent Minister of the Interior asserted that the Linas-Marcoussis
Agreement was "null and void". The situation was compounded by the
apparently ambivalent position of President Gbagbo who, on his return
from Paris, referred to the Agreement as "proposals".
In an address to the nation on 7 February 2003,
President Gbagbo confirmed the appointment of Mr. Diarra as the
new Prime Minister and requested him to propose a new cabinet. At
the same time, the President asserted that he intended to retain
all his constitutional prerogatives, and that he would not implement
those provisions of the Linas-Marcoussis Agreement he considered
to be at variance with the Constitution of Côte d'Ivoire. In particular,
he took exception to the provision making the appointment of the
Prime Minister irrevocable, and to the proposed disarmament of the
national armed forces. The President also rejected the allocation
of the Defence and Interior Ministries to the rebel movements.
Despite the mixed signals emanating from the President,
his address to the nation had the positive effect of calming the
situation, as the street demonstrations in Abidjan ceased. In other
encouraging developments, the leaders of the defence and security
forces announced that they were no longer opposed to the participation
of the rebel movements in a new government, provided the rebels
renounced their claim to the key portfolios of defence and the interior.
Seven political parties signatories to the Linas-Marcoussis Agreement
also publicly expressed their support for the allocation of some
posts in the new government of national reconciliation to the rebel
movements. For their part, the three rebel movements and Mr. Ouattara's
RDR party denounced what they perceived as President Gbagbo's departures
from the Agreement.
Efforts by the ECOWAS Contact Group on Côte d'Ivoire
to break the impasse on the implementation of the Agreement culminated
in a summit meeting attended by President Eyadéma, together with
the President of Ghana, John Agyekum Kufuor, and the President of
Nigeria, Olusegun Obasanjo, as well as the Interim Chairman of the
Commission of the African Union, Amara Essy, and the Vice-President
of South Africa, Jacob Zuma, with President Gbagbo in Yamoussoukro
on 10 February 2003. Mr. Diarra travelled to Yamoussoukro with the
ECOWAS heads of State and was installed as Prime Minister on that
occasion. The meeting explored alternative arrangements for the
allocation of posts in the new government of national unity that
could be acceptable to all parties. The rebel movements refused
to attend, however, on the grounds that they did not wish to renegotiate
the understandings already reached in Paris.
Following his installation, Prime Minister Diarra
held extensive consultations on the composition of the government
of national reconciliation with all concerned Ivorian parties, as
well as the President of Ghana, the current Chairman of ECOWAS,
and with other leaders of the region. However, the consultations
were inconclusive, as the rebels continued to insist on having the
defence and interior portfolios. In addition, President Gbagbo appeared
reluctant to delegate the necessary authority to the Prime Minister,
as required under the Linas-Marcoussis Agreement, and insisted that
he would have the final say on the composition of the new government.
Mr. Diarra presented a provisional cabinet list on two occasions,
but President Gbagbo drew up a different list. Consequently, following
a meeting with the rebel movements in Bouaké on 3 March 2003, during
which the movements refused to compromise on the sticking point
of the defence and interior posts, the Prime Minister warned that
he would consider resigning if his efforts to form the new government
continued to encounter obstacles.
Some progress towards breaking the stalemate was
finally made at a meeting of the 10 signatories to the Linas-Marcoussis
Agreement, which was convened in Accra from 6 to 8 March 2003 by
President Kufuor as the current Chairman of ECOWAS. At that meeting
the parties agreed to create a 15-member National Security Council
comprising representatives of each of the 10 signatories, as well
as the army, the gendarmerie, the police, President Gbagbo and Prime
Minister Diarra, to oversee the functioning of the disputed posts
of defence and the interior. They also requested the Prime Minister
to submit candidates for the two ministries, who would be appointed
by consensus, and they reached a new understanding on the allocation
of the other cabinet posts. Subsequently, on 10 March, President
Gbagbo issued a decree delegating authority to the Prime Minister
to implement the work programme set out in the Linas-Marcoussis
Agreement, but only for a six-month period. In another positive
development, which could contribute towards building confidence
among the warring parties, on 11 March representatives of the rebel
movements travelled to the Government-held city of Yamoussoukro
and met with President Gbagbo for further talks on the formation
of the new government. Efforts were also made to convene the new
government at Yamoussoukro, on 13 March, but the Cabinet members
nominated by the three rebel movements and Mr. Ouattara's RDR party
refused to attend, citing security reasons.
CHRONOLOGY (March 2003
- April 2004)